Back to BlogLean Manufacturing
Batch vs Discrete Manufacturing: MES Differences and Guide
Understand the differences between batch and discrete manufacturing and how MES systems adapt. Learn recipes, routing, and production tracking for each type.
8 min read
Share:
Batch vs Discrete Manufacturing: MES Differences and Guide
Meta Description: Understand the differences between batch and discrete manufacturing and how MES systems adapt. Learn recipes, routing, and production tracking for each type.
Introduction
Manufacturing operations fall into two primary categories: discrete and batch manufacturing. While both produce physical goods, their processes, controls, and MES requirements differ significantly. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting and implementing the right MES solution.
Manufacturing Types Defined
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Manufacturing Type Comparison │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ │
│ DISCRETE MANUFACTURING │
│ • Individual units produced │
│ • Assembly operations │
│ • Bills of materials │
│ • Routing (operations sequence) │
│ • Examples: Auto parts, electronics, machinery │
│ │
│ BATCH/PROCESS MANUFACTURING │
│ • Materials undergo chemical change │
│ • Formula/recipe driven │
│ • Flow operations │
│ • Parameters and setpoints │
│ • Examples: Chemicals, food, pharmaceuticals │
│ │
│ HYBRID MANUFACTURING │
│ • Combination of both │
│ • Discrete components from batch materials │
│ • Examples: Coated products, assembled foods │
│ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Discrete Manufacturing
Characteristics and MES Needs
DISCRETE MANUFACTURING FEATURES:
PRODUCTION CHARACTERISTICS:
• Individual, countable products
• Assembly operations
• Component-based construction
• Routing through workstations
• Work orders by quantity
KEY DATA ELEMENTS:
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Bill of Materials (BOM) │
│ • Parent-component relationships │
│ • Quantity per assembly │
│ • Effectivity dates │
│ • Subassemblies │
│ │
│ Routing │
│ • Sequence of operations │
│ • Work centers │
│ • Standard times │
│ • Tooling requirements │
│ │
│ Work Orders │
│ • Product │
│ • Quantity │
│ • Due date │
│ • Priority │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
MES REQUIREMENTS:
• Production tracking by unit
• Genealogy/traceability
• Work order management
• Routing enforcement
• Labor tracking
• Quality at each operation
• WIP tracking
Batch Manufacturing
Characteristics and MES Needs
BATCH MANUFACTURING FEATURES:
PRODUCTION CHARACTERISTICS:
• Materials blended, mixed, reacted
• Recipe/formula driven
• Parameter control (temperature, pressure)
• Phases and operations
• Batch records
KEY DATA ELEMENTS:
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Formula/Recipe │
│ • Ingredients and quantities │
│ • Proportions │
│ • Substitutions │
│ • Versions │
│ │
│ Recipe │
│ • Formula + procedure │
│ • Phases and operations │
│ • Parameters │
│ • Equipment requirements │
│ │
│ Batch Record │
│ • Actual ingredients used │
│ • Actual parameter values │
│ • Time stamps │
│ • Operator actions │
│ • Quality results │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
MES REQUIREMENTS:
• Recipe management
• Batch execution
• Parameter monitoring and control
• Electronic batch records (EBR)
• Weigh and dispense
• Material verification
• Deviation handling
• Regulatory compliance
Key Differences
BOM vs. Formula
| Aspect | BOM (Discrete) | Formula/Recipe (Batch) |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Hierarchical | List of ingredients |
| Quantities | Fixed counts | Proportions/weights |
| Substitutions | Engineering change | Flexible per batch |
| Scaling | Linear per unit | Variable batch sizes |
| Versioning | Effectivity dates | Formula versions |
Key Differences
Routing vs. Recipe
ROUTING (DISCRETE):
• Operations in sequence
• Work centers/machines
• Setup and run times
• Parallel operations possible
• Can skip operations
• Rework loops
RECIPE (BATCH):
• Phases and operations
• Equipment classes/units
• Parameter-driven
• Sequential processing
• Phase dependencies
• Hold points
EXAMPLE COMPARISON:
Discrete - Making a Table:
Operation 10: Cut parts → Saw
Operation 20: Drill holes → Drill press
Operation 30: Assemble → Assembly bench
Operation 40: Finish → Finishing station
Operation 50: Package → Packing area
Batch - Making Paint:
Phase 1: Weigh pigments → Scale
Phase 2: Mix with base → Mixer 1
Phase 3: Heat to 80°C → Reactor
Phase 4: Hold 30 minutes → Reactor
Phase 5: Cool to 30°C → Cooler
Phase 6: Add additives → Mixer 2
Phase 7: Filter → Filter press
Phase 8: Fill containers → Filling line
Production Tracking
How MES Tracks Each Type
DISCRETE TRACKING:
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Serial/Unit Tracking: │
│ • Each unit has serial number │
│ • Track through each operation │
│ • Record labor and time │
│ • Capture quality data │
│ • Build genealogy │
│ │
│ Status Tracking: │
│ • Not started │
│ • In-process │
│ • Completed │
│ • Scrapped │
│ • Rework │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
BATCH TRACKING:
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Batch Tracking: │
│ • Batch number/lot ID │
│ • Track phase execution │
│ • Record parameters and values │
│ • Capture deviations │
│ • Build material genealogy │
│ │
│ Status Tracking: │
│ • Not started │
│ • In-progress (by phase) │
│ • On hold │
│ • Completed │
│ • Deviated │
│ • Discarded │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Material Control
Inventory Management Differences
DISCRETE MATERIAL CONTROL:
• Part numbers for components
• Unit of measure = each
• Backflushing common
• Kit picking for work orders
• Component shortages hold production
• Serial tracking for key components
BATCH MATERIAL CONTROL:
• Material numbers for ingredients
• Unit of measure = weight/volume
• Weigh and dispense
• Lot-controlled ingredients
• Potency adjustments
• Bulk material management
• Shelf-life considerations
Quality Integration
Quality in Each Environment
DISCRETE QUALITY:
• Inspection at operations
• Pass/fail criteria
• Visual inspection
• Dimensional measurement
• Functional testing
• Defect recording
• Rework routing
• Scrap reporting
BATCH QUALITY:
• In-process testing
• Lab samples and results
• Parameter validation
• Hold points
• Certificate of analysis
• Potency/purity verification
• Stability testing
• Shelf-life dating
Equipment Management
Asset Requirements
DISCRETE EQUIPMENT:
• Work centers defined
• Machine capabilities
• Tooling requirements
• Setup considerations
• Maintenance scheduling
• Capacity planning
• Equipment availability
BATCH EQUIPMENT:
• Equipment classes
• Unit suitability (size, material)
• Cleaning requirements
• Calibration requirements
• Parameter capabilities
• Instrumentation
• Sanitary design considerations
Regulatory Compliance
Documentation Requirements
DISCRETE COMPLIANCE:
• Traceability requirements
• Safety standards
• Industry-specific regulations
• Component documentation
• Test records
BATCH COMPLIANCE:
• Electronic batch records (EBR)
• Signature requirements (21 CFR Part 11)
• Recipe version control
• Material traceability
• Deviation documentation
• Validation documentation
• Audit trail requirements
• GMP requirements
Hybrid Manufacturing
Combining Both Worlds
HYBRID MANUFACTURING EXAMPLES:
Paint Manufacturing:
• Batch: Mix paint (recipe)
• Discrete: Fill cans (assembly)
• MES: Batch execution + packaging tracking
Food Products:
• Batch: Prepare product (recipe)
• Discrete: Package products (assembly)
• MES: Recipe management + packaging execution
Pharmaceuticals:
• Batch: Active ingredient (recipe)
• Discrete: Fill and package (assembly)
• MES: EBR + packaging track and trace
Automotive Components:
• Batch: Coatings and treatments (recipe)
• Discrete: Component assembly (BOM)
• MES: Both recipe and routing execution
CHALLENGES:
• Complex integration
• Different tracking mechanisms
• Separate quality requirements
• Combined reporting
MES Selection
Choosing the Right System
SELECTION CRITERIA:
FOR DISCRETE MANUFACTURING:
• Strong BOM management
• Routing capabilities
• Serial/lot tracking
• Genealogy tracking
• WIP tracking
• Labor management
• Shop floor scheduling
FOR BATCH MANUFACTURING:
• Recipe management
• Batch execution
• Electronic batch records
• Parameter management
• Weigh and dispense
• Deviation handling
• Regulatory compliance
FOR HYBRID MANUFACTURING:
• Both BOM and recipe support
• Mixed-mode tracking
• Integrated quality
• Flexible reporting
• Unified genealogy
Implementation Considerations
Deployment Differences
DISCRETE MES IMPLEMENTATION:
• Focus on work order execution
• Shop floor data collection
• Routing enforcement
• Material logistics
• Labor tracking
• Equipment integration
BATCH MES IMPLEMENTATION:
• Focus on recipe management
• Batch execution
• EBR implementation
• Parameter integration
• Quality integration
• Regulatory compliance
COMMON ELEMENTS:
• Work order management
• Material management
• Equipment management
• Quality management
• Reporting and analytics
Best Practices
Success Principles
-
Understand Your Process
- Map your manufacturing type
- Identify unique requirements
- Don't force wrong model
-
Choose Appropriate MES
- Purpose-built for your type
- Flexible for future needs
- Integration capabilities
-
Design for Your Process
- Reflect actual operations
- Don't automate bad processes
- Plan for improvement
-
Plan for Integration
- Connect to ERP properly
- Quality system integration
- Equipment connectivity
-
Train for Your Process
- Role-based training
- Process-specific procedures
- Ongoing support
Conclusion
Understanding the differences between discrete and batch manufacturing is fundamental to selecting and implementing the right MES. While both share common elements, their unique requirements demand different approaches to production tracking, material management, and quality control.
Choose the right MES for your manufacturing type. Contact us to discuss solutions tailored to your operations.
Related Topics: MES Selection Guide, Recipe Management, BOM Management
#mes#erp#lean
Related Articles
Lean ManufacturingLean ManufacturingLean ManufacturingLean Manufacturing
Manufacturing Analytics: Data-Driven Decision Guide
8 min
Just-in-Time Manufacturing: Complete Implementation Guide
8 min
Supply Chain Visibility: Manufacturing Tracking Guide
9 min
Factory Automation Solutions: Comprehensive Implementation Guide
8 min